Dear Penina,
I’ve been married for many years, and I’ve never written a letter like this. I’m not even sure exactly what I’m asking.
My wife is a good person. She’s a devoted mother, she runs our home well, and people respect her. But with me, she isn’t warm. She doesn’t hug me or sit close to me on the couch. I can’t remember the last time she told me she loved me without me saying it first.
Our marriage feels like a business arrangement. She has a list of things she needs from me: Fix the cabinet, pick up the kids, call the plumber, deal with the bank. I do them, and I don’t mind helping. But when I do something, there’s no thank you and no sign that she even noticed. When I don’t do something, or do it the “wrong” way, I hear about it right away.
The things she criticizes me for seem so small to me. I loaded the dishwasher wrong. I left my shoes by the door. I’ve tried to change those things, but there’s always something new. Some days I feel like I’m living with a supervisor, not a wife.
What I miss most is feeling respected. I work hard, and I try to be a good husband and father. I would give a lot to hear her tell someone she’s proud of me, or to see her look happy when I walk in the door.
We enjoy vacations together, but holidays have been more tense recently because of her criticism and lack of interest in connection. She’s always too busy for a date night, or even just to go for a walk or sit and have coffee together. She’s always running and doing. I understand that she works, but she makes time to walk with a friend, go to the gym and do anything the kids ask for, even late at night.
We tried therapy. It ended up hurting more. I opened up about what I need, and she dismissed my feelings in the session, even with the therapist trying to help her understand and learn how to show care for my feelings. Then she would be upset at me after the session, and nothing changed. I felt like I had made myself vulnerable for nothing. If I do what she wants, there is less tension, but from what I’ve seen, it doesn’t make her more loving.
I’m starting to wonder if this is just who she is, and if I need to accept that this is my marriage and stop hoping for more. Is there any hope for me to have a more connected marriage, or do I have to make peace with it?
Sincerely,
Running Out of Hope
Dear Running Out of Hope,
I am so sorry that you are in this painful spot and feeling so alone, hopeless and helpless. This type of personality clash or gap happens quite often, and there is hope to bridge the gap. Actually, many couples are different emotionally, and it can work quite well.
From what you describe, it sounds like even if your wife wants a more fulfilling marriage, and even though she went to therapy, her emotional range may be limited. It sounds like she has difficulty with closeness and connection. You mention that she has friends and makes time for them. My guess is that she probably isn’t very vulnerable with anyone, and that she doesn’t focus much on what is missing in her relationships. She is more of a worker and a doer. She keeps busy, and she doesn’t sit with her feelings. Without even realizing it, she may not be able to be vulnerable or to sit with your feelings, and both of those are needed for a close connection. That would also explain why the therapy sessions were so hard for her and why she was upset afterward. Being asked to slow down and feel can be very uncomfortable for someone who copes by staying busy.
She will probably never be gushy or exactly what you are picturing in a partner. However, progress can be made. With her personality and life experience, it will take longer and need more patience, but that is very different from no hope.
My suggestions are the following:
Don’t give up on therapy. One hard experience doesn’t mean therapy can’t work for you. Try to find the right fit. Interview therapists on the phone first, do your research, and look for someone who specializes in couples work, such as Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT). Then give it time, and don’t expect results right away. You should feel that the sessions are helpful, but progress with connection takes time. Sometimes you may both feel uncomfortable after a session, and within reason, that is part of the growth process.
Try to understand her too, and what is hard for her. Be curious about her. What was closeness like in the home she grew up in? Was affection shown, or was love shown by working hard and taking care of things? Does staying busy protect her from feelings she doesn’t know what to do with? Even her criticism about small things may be her way of saying she feels overwhelmed or that she is carrying a lot. Understanding her doesn’t mean your needs don’t matter. It may help you take her coldness less personally, and it may help her feel safe enough to open up.
Soften how you bring up issues with her. Be less critical and judgmental, and focus more on helping her understand you. Instead of “You never have time for me,” try “I miss you. When we go a whole week without any time together, I feel lonely in our marriage.” She is much more likely to hear that than something that sounds like another complaint.
Try to spend some time together every day, even if it’s short, and explain to her why it is so important to you. Ten or 15 minutes over coffee, or a short walk after dinner, is a good place to start. Since she already makes time to walk with a friend, you might ask whether she’d walk with you one or two evenings a week. Keep it light and enjoyable, not another time to work through problems.
Do a love languages quiz together, and explain to her that you think you are both not meeting each other’s needs and are both frustrated. It sounds like acts of service may matter a lot to her, while words of appreciation and physical affection matter a lot to you. You are already giving her what she asks for, and she may not realize that it isn’t landing for you the same way. Seeing it laid out can help her understand that you aren’t asking for something unreasonable. You’re asking to be loved in a way you can feel.
You asked whether you have to accept your differences or whether there is hope. I think the answer is some of both. I see this couple dynamic quite often in my practice, and there is hope. Accepting who she is doesn’t mean giving up on more connection. It means having realistic expectations, so that small steps toward each other can count, rather than feeling like failures because they aren’t everything you wished for.
I wish you hatzlacha. It may take time, but if you approach this with patience, understanding and care for both of your needs, I believe you can build a warmer and more connected marriage.
Sincerely,
Penina
Penina Flug, LCSW, has dedicated over two decades to helping individuals, couples and families. She received her master’s degree in social work from Fordham University in 2003 and advanced training in Emotionally Focused Couples Therapy (EFT) in 2015. Her private practice focuses on relationship therapy and premarital education. Penina is also a passionate advocate for premarital education within the Jewish community and contributes to the field by training premarital educators, including kallah teachers. She can be reached at dearpenina@peninafluglcsw.com or peninafluglcsw.com.